Authority

Home Up General Info Bible Study Corr. Course Links Change of address

Expediency – Lawful or Unlawful

Introduction:
1. It would be difficult to over emphasize the importance 
   of our subject for tonight.
2. We must have scriptural authority for everything that we 
   teach or practice in order to be acceptable to God.
3. Churches of Christ have ever been dedicated to the 
   proposition that we will give Scriptural authority for 
   everything we teach or practice or else we will give it 
   up.
4. Or, if anybody will show by the Scriptures that we 
   should teach or practice something which we are not, 
   that we will begin immediately to do so.
5. For any person or church to fail in this proposition is 
   but to reject the Lordship of Jesus Christ.
I. What do we mean by an expedient?
      1. “Useful for effecting a desired result; suited 
         to the circumstances or the occasion; 
         advantageous; convenient.”
         “n. 1. an expedient thing; means to an end.” 
         Webster’s New World Dictionary
A. “Expedient” from the Greek “SUMPHERO” – used 14 
   times in the New Testament.
        1. It is translated “good” in Matthew 19:10.
        2. It is translated “profitable” in Matthew 5:29; 
           5:30; 18:6; Acts 20:20.
        3. It is translated “profit” in 1 Corinthians 12:7; 
           Hebrews 12:10.
        4. It is translated “expedient” in John 11:50; 
           16:7; 18:14; 2 Corinthians 12:1; 1 Corinthians 
           6:12; 10:23.
        5. The word is used in 1 Corinthians 6:12 and 10:23 
           in the sense in which we are interested in it 
           tonight.
        6. But these two passages have been much abused.
        7. Some seem to think that Paul’s use of the 
           expression “all things are lawful for me” 
           indicates that the realm of expediency is a 
           catch all category by which they can justify all 
           of their unlawful desires and wild unlawful 
           practices.
     B. In both of these passages Paul is applying a 
        principle to two subjects of discussion which were 
        closely related to heathen worship.
        1. Whether it was lawful for Christians to eat food 
           which had been offered in sacrifices to idols; 
           and,
        2. Whether it was permissible to overlook in 
           Christians, indulgence in the sin of 
           fornication.
        3. It seems that, because of Paul affirmed the 
           right of Christian liberty in relation to the 
           heathen food, some at Corinth apparently 
           concluded that Christians had liberty to 
           practice the immoralities that were associated 
           with the heathen worship.
        4. When Paul used the expression “all things” he is 
           stating the principle as it pertains 
           particularly to the eating of meats sacrificed 
           to idols, as evidenced by verse 13 and chapter 
           10.
        5. Nothing could be lawful to Paul which was 
           unlawful.
        6. Paul argues that we do not have the right to do 
           even that which is lawful, if it is hurtful to 
           ourselves and others.
        7. Paul is emphasizing that there is a lawful use 
           of the appetites and desires which God has given 
           man, but none of them must obtain power or 
           mastery over us.
        8. All God given appetites and passions are for our 
           good, if properly used and restrained.
        9. However, if they enslave us, they degrade and 
           destroy us.
       10. The Corinthians were apparently becoming 
           enslaved to sin, by the very freedom which they 
           desired.  Paul says he would not come under the      
           power or mastery of any.
       11. Paul shows that there is a very basic difference 
           in the eating of meat sacrificed to idols and 
           the committing of fornication. Verses 13-20.
       12. Commentators generally think that verse 12 of 1 
           Corinthians 6 is a rather abrupt change of 
           thought from that which has proceeded.
       13. Perhaps it is not so abrupt, however.
       14. See Verse 9-11.  Paul affirms that the 
           unrighteous shall not inherit the kingdom of 
           God.  Then he lists sins of unrighteousness of 
           which some of them had been guiltily.  These 
           included fornication, adultery, and others.  But 
           he says those at Corinth had been washed, 
           sanctified, and justified.
       15. Apparently they were claiming freedom to go back 
           to committing fornication.
       16. The remainder of this chapter is used to show 
           the exceeding sinfulness of fornication.
       17. Thus Paul announces that a thing cannot be 
           expedient unless it is first lawful.  A person 
           does not have freedom or liberty to do anything 
           unless it is lawful, and even then there are 
           some lawful things which are not expedient.
       18. A failure to understand this and to properly 
           apply the principle is the source of much 
           religious error.
       19. Let me emphasize again, that to prove that 
           anything is expedient, it must first be proved 
           to be lawful and even then may not be expedient.
       20. To assume that anything is expedient before 
           proving it to be lawful is simply begging the 
           question at issue.
       21. Those who attempt to prove that a thing is 
           lawful by claiming it to be expedient are in 
           reverse.  They have the proverbial “cart before 
           the horse”.
       22. Yet, whenever authority is wanted for a practice 
           for which no authority exists, people, including 
           those who profess to be members of the Lord’s 
           church, including preachers who should know 
           better, immediately invoke the law of expediency 
           in an effort to attempt a justification of their 
           cause.
 II. Note some principles regulating expediency.
     1. There is realm regulated by expediency.
     2. Expediency is within the realm of Divine law.
     3. Expediency involves that which is authorized, but 
        things where in Christians have a choice.  This 
        involves the area of General and Specific commands 
        which we will get to in just a few minutes.
     4. 1 Corinthians 10:23 teaches that a thing is not 
        expedient unless it edifies, (that is, builds up, 
        strengthens, promotes spiritual growth and 
        development of ourselves and others).
     5. 1 Corinthians 10:31 teaches that a thing is not 
        expedient unless it glorifies God.
     6. 1 Corinthians 10:27-32 teaches that a thing is not 
        expedient if it “offends” or “leads others to sin”.
        a. This involves non-believers. Verse 27
        b. 1 Corinthians 8:11-13 teaches the same regarding 
           causing a brother to sin.
        c. In both instances individual conscience is 
           involved.
           (1) There is nothing to indicate that this 
               involves or applies to congregational 
               action.
           (2) It this applied to congregational action 
               then any and every person who comes up with 
               a wild idea could kill the effective work of 
               the church and the oversight of the elders 
               while they insisted that their conscience 
               had to be respected.
III. There are two kinds of Authority – General and 
     Specific.
        1. General Authority is that which pertains to, or 
           is applicable to, each and all of a class, kind 
           or order; as a general law – not specific.  It 
           included anything, method, or means of execution 
           that comes within the class or order of that 
           authorized.
        2. Specific Authority is that which is precisely 
           formulated or restricted; specifying, explicit; 
           as a specific statement.  It excludes 
           everything, method or means of execution in the 
           same order or class which is not particularly 
           specified in that which is authorized.
        3. Many specific commands are both specific and 
           generic.
        4. Maurice Barnett’s illustration of Generic and 
           Specific from the August 1982 issue of Torch 
           Magazine, page 14.
     A. Let’s look at some illustrations:
        1. Genesis 6:13-14 – God said to Noah… “Make thee 
           an ark of gopher wood.”
           a. This specifies the kind of wood.
           b. Excludes all other kind of wood (Pine, 
              Poplar, Oak, Cedar, Hickory, etc.)
           c. Other things specified – Length – breadth – 
              height – one window – one door in the side – 
              covered with pitch within and without – 
              three stories.
           d. Expedient – Place to build the ark – Number 
              of rooms within the ark – tools to be used, 
              hammers, saws, adzes, etc.  Noah could have 
              fastened the timbers together with wooden 
              pins, by notching, dovetailing, etc.
              (1) These are not necessarily non-essentials 
                  as they are often referred to.
              (2) Noah did have to have a place to build 
                  the ark, were rooms to be made, he did 
                  have to have tools, etc.,
              (3) But these are things in which Noah had a 
                  choice, in that they were not specified.
              (4) These were things necessary to expedite 
                  the carrying out of the command to build 
                  the ark.  Hence, the realm of 
                  “expediency”.
           e. If Noah had added a fourth story or made only 
              two, he would have gone beyond, or else 
              diminished from God’s command.
           f. If he had used Oak instead of gopher wood, 
              he would have substituted something not 
              commanded.
           g. Had he put the door in the end rather than 
              the side, he would have altered or changed a 
              specific detail of the pattern.
           h. From this it should become obvious that an 
              expedient can be only a way, method, or 
              something used to facilitate or help carry 
              out an authorized command.
           i. It cannot alter or change the nature of the 
              thing authorized.
        2. Deuteronomy 21:4 – The Elders of a city were to 
           take an heifer, which hath not been wrought 
           with, and which hath not drawn in the yoke;
           a. In this instance the Elders could take a 
              heifer of one year, two years, three years, 
              etc., as long as it had never worked.
           b. They could take a heifer of any color, 
              white, black, red, black and white, brindle, 
              etc.
           c. They would still be doing what God commanded.
        3. Numbers 19:2 – “This is the ordinance of the law 
           which the Lord hath commanded, saying, Speak 
           unto the children of Israel, that they bring a 
           red heifer without spot, wherein is no blemish, 
           and upon which never came yoke:”
           a. The difference between this command and the 
              last is obvious.
           b. Now they cannot bring a white heifer.  Or 
              black, or brindle.  Now the heifer has to be 
              a red heifer.
           c. Also added is that it is to be without spot 
              or blemish.
        4. Hebrews 10:25 – Command to Assemble to worship.
           a. Come together in one place. 1 Corinthians 
              14:23, 26; 11:20, 33.
           b. Inherent in the command to Assemble is a 
              “Place” or a facility to accommodate the 
              coming together.
           c. But the place or facility is not specified.
           d. Brethren have to choose whether they will 
              build and provide a meeting house suited for 
              the purpose, assemble out by the Riverside 
              under a brush arbor, assemble in a third 
              story loft, or make other arrangements.
              (1) These are expedients in carrying out the 
                  command to assemble, but they do not 
                  change the nature of the worship.
              (2) I have had preachers say to me, “We don’t 
                  have authority for the church building.”
              (3) When I hear statements like this I know 
                  that they have little or no concept of 
                  or understanding of How to Establish 
                  Bible Authority.
           e. Other things not specified and left to the 
              discretion of the Saints:
              (1) Time of assemblies – Morning, Afternoon, 
                  Evening.
              (2) Such Expedients as seats, lights, heat, 
                  air-conditioning, rest rooms, water 
                  fountain, etc.
              (3) In such matters the church has a choice 
                  to decide what is best for all concerned.
              (4) They are not changing the nature of the 
                  assembling in anyway.
        5. Matthew 28:19-20 – Teach – Observe All Things
           a. The Method of teaching is not specified.
           b. Thus we can teach publicly, or privately or 
              in classes.
           c. We can teach on Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, 
              etc.
           d. We can teach orally, or in writing; Radio; 
              T.V.; or even the telephone.
           e. We can use the blackboard, charts, slides, 
              overhead projection, etc.
           f. We are still simply obeying the command to 
              teach.
        6. Matthew 28:19; Mark 16:15 – Go – Preach the 
           Gospel.
           a. But the means of going is not specified.
           b. A preacher can walk; ride a horse, bicycle, 
              motorcycle, train, automobile, but etc.; He 
              may go by boat, or by airplane.
           c. He is simply carrying out the command to go.
        7. 1 Corinthians 16:1-2 – Giving is Authorized
           a. Day is specified.
           b. Brethren may get up and bring their 
              contribution down to the front as I have seen 
              done and have known of some contending had to 
              be done.
           c. Or brethren may determine, as most all have 
              done, that it is more orderly and better to 
              pass a basket or plate.  Or even pass a hat.
           d. In either instance they are simply obeying 
              the command to give.
        8. Matthew 28:19-20; Mark 16:15-16 – Commanded to 
           Baptize Those Who Are Taught And Who Believe.
           a. But it doesn’t specify the place.
           b. It doesn’t specify whether a lake, river, 
              pond, or baptistery, etc.
           c. It doesn’t specify whether running water, or 
              still.
           d. It doesn’t specify the position – whether 
              backward, forward, sidewise, or prostrate.
           e. Hence, we can choose the most expedient place 
              or position to carry out the command to 
              baptize.
           f. To Baptize infants who can neither be taught 
              nor believe would violate the command.
        9. Ephesians 5:19; Colossians 3:16 – We Are 
           Commanded to Sing Psalms, Hymns, and Spiritual 
           Songs.
           a. The command to sing is both specific and            
              generic.
           b. Sing specifies Vocal Music. – It therefore of 
              necessity excludes any other kind of music, 
              such as Mechanical Instrumental Music.
              (1) To use Mechanical Instruments of Music is 
                  to change the nature of the thing done.
              (2) It is to add to God’s Command.
           c. Sing Psalms, Hymns, and Spiritual Songs 
              limits the kind of songs we can sing.
              (1) For example we would violate the command 
                  to try to use “rock and roll” songs in 
                  the worship.
           d. Yet the command is generic because of the 
              many options still left.
              (1) Whether to have a song leader, or who is 
                  to lead; the number of songs; whether to 
                  sing four part harmony and if so, whether 
                  to sing soprano, alto, bass, tenor; etc.
              (2) The order of songs.
              (3) These are all choices which we are to 
                  make.  These are the areas of expediency.
           e. Inherent in the command to sing is pitch.
              (1) We cannot sing without pitch.  It may not 
                  be the right pitch.  It may be high or 
                  low, even off key, but we still have 
                  pitch.
              (2) Although pitch inheres in the command to 
                  sing, we are not told how to obtain the 
                  pitch.
              (3) We may obtain the pitch from memory, a 
                  pitch pipe, or a tuning fork (pitch 
                  fork?).
              (4) Regardless which of these methods are 
                  used to obtain the pitch, we are still 
                  obeying the command to sing.
              (5) If we sing and play a mechanical 
                  instrument of music we have added another 
                  kind of music which God has not 
                  authorized.
Howard See
Top of the page

Back Home Up Next